Memorials Matter: Emotion, Environment, and Public Memory at American Historical Sites

By Jennifer K. Ladino. University of Nevada Press, 2019. 
From the sculptured peaks of Mount Rushmore to the Coloradan prairie lands at Sand Creek to the idyllic islands of the Pacific, the West’s signature environments add a new dimension to the study of memorials. In such diverse and often dramatic landscapes, how do the natural and built environments shape our emotions? In Memorials Matter, Jennifer Ladino investigates the physical environments of seven diverse National Park Service (NPS) sites in the American West and how they influence emotions about historical conflict and national identity. Chapters feature the region’s diverse inhabitants (Mexican, Chinese, Japanese, African, and Native Americans) and the variously traumatic histories these groups endured—histories of oppression, exploitation, incarceration, slavery, and genocide. Drawing on material ecocritical theory, Ladino emphasizes how memorials evoke visceral responses that are not always explicitly “storied,” but nevertheless matter in powerful ways. The book develops several new theoretical terms that help articulate those visceral responses, including “affective agency”–a complement to what ecocritics have called “narrative agency”–and “affective dissonance,” a counterpart to the psychological concept of cognitive dissonance.

In this blend of narrative scholarship and critical theory, Ladino demonstrates how these memorial sites and their surrounding landscapes, combined with written texts, generate emotion and shape our collective memory of traumatic events. More broadly, Memorials Matter urges us to consider our everyday environments and to become attuned to features and feelings we might otherwise overlook.